5 Common Mistakes Clubs Make with Player Award Voting
February 2026 | 6 min read
Most clubs have good intentions when it comes to player voting. But common mistakes can undermine the results, create disputes, and leave players and parents feeling frustrated. Here are the five biggest errors — and how to avoid every one of them.
1 Not Setting Clear Rules Before the Season
Vague criteria lead to inconsistent voting. If coaches don't know whether they're assessing effort, skill, attendance, or sportsmanship, every vote is based on a different standard.
2 Relying on a Single Voter Type
Coach-only voting can introduce bias — conscious or not. A single perspective means a single point of failure, and it doesn't capture the full picture of a player's contribution.
3 Leaving Voting Until End of Season
Asking coaches to remember who played well 18 weeks ago is unreliable. Recency bias dominates — the players who performed well in the last few rounds get an unfair advantage.
4 Using Systems Without an Audit Trail
Paper voting and spreadsheets can't prove integrity when challenged. If a parent disputes the result, you have no way to show how votes were collected, when they were submitted, or how the tally was calculated.
5 Forgetting About the Presentation
You've spent all season collecting and tallying votes — but the awards presentation is thrown together at the last minute. Rushed slides, missing information, and awkward silences undermine all the work that went into the voting.
GameVote Prevents All Five Mistakes
Clear rules, multiple voter types, round-by-round voting, full audit trail, and auto-generated presentations — all built in. Try it free for 14 days.